Do I have a fix? Nope. Do you?
I'll take that challenge…
The reason racing is on life support in this part of the country is because the tracks can’t be logical and consistent enough to stay open. We all know the drill – new track operator, big talk and plans, but as things go on, cracks develop. Nonsensical or emotionally-driven decisions happen (sudden rule or payout changes), racers and fans are driven off, the cycle to the bottom happens, in four months to three years that promoter is out of business. New operator comes in, cycle repeats, then he is gone in three years or less,
Everyone knows that pattern by now, so for a couple of years no one commits any significant money in new equipment, especially if the classes aren’t close to what already exists in the immediate area, and the payouts don’t make relative sense between the classes, given the relative out of pocket expenses (my original point in this thread). Which of course creates the beginning of the downward spiral.
So then the track operator starts looking to add cheaper, less interesting classes where he can finagle his expense to revenue ratio better, so he can pay the bills. Suddenly you have eight classes running, with half of them being miniature vehicles. Racers spend all race day waiting on other people for a few minutes to practice so they can hope to be competitive. The audience comes to an expensive facility to find a program subsisting on $2000-5000 cars, and wonders about the value of the experience. Then they spend a drawn out night waiting for their few favorite classes, most of it under expensive floodlights, further detracting from the value equation. The cycle to the bottom continues.
What’s the biggest problem in this picture, that you can change? Classes and rules. Classes and rules cause the confusion and the inequity. Classes and rules cause the drawn out programs. Classes and rules mean you have clear disparities *within* the classes and lack of competition. Classes and rules cause the friction between the racers and the track.
What’s the alternative? Bracket racing, of course, adapted to oval racing. You would have to separate cars by size, for safety reasons. But there would be no reason to separate them by what body they have, what components are in them, or how fast they are. In fact, in the context of bracket racing, those differences would add excitement, rather than create silos.
No more buying a new set of racing tires each outing. No more spending all day at the track waiting on other people so you can practice or working on your car to get an extra tenth. No need for the operator to worry about whether he is compensating or incentivizing the classes properly in relation to each other. No barriers to entry (and fewer reasons to leave) because you can't afford a class you like. Once it is going, no need for a new track operator to reinvent the wheel, causing community disruption.
There are multiple benefits, this is just a sample. This would never happen instantaneously. Like any new format it would have to be developed, understood and promoted. But I can see it being extremely interesting from both fan and racer points of view. Most importantly, it would be much, much more competitive. No more freight train racing, where the drama evaporates as the race drones on. In this case, drama would build as the race progresses.
I have some thoughts (and one concern) about how this would work in practice, but I see it as a doable realistic solution that addresses many of the current problems. I’ll stop now and throw this out for comments.